Donald Trump’s Obstruction of Congressional Oversight

Congressional oversight of executive branch officials is fundamental to our democracy and our constitutional system of checks and balances — a system the Trump administration appears determined to delegitimize. The Trump White House’s blanket refusal to comply with congressional requests and subpoenas isn’t just unprecedented. It signals a dangerous vision of a presidency left unchecked and unscrutinized. American Oversight is examining executive branch agencies’ defiance of congressional investigations — and whether those agencies have been acting at the direction of the White House.

Background

President Donald Trump is facing a number of legitimate investigations, from his business dealings and his taxes to his efforts to interfere in the Mueller investigation. And his administration is fighting all of them to an unprecedented degree, with the president on April 24, 2019, going so far as to say, “We’re fighting all the subpoenas.”

The next month, White House Counsel Pat Cipollone wrote to the House Judiciary Committee stating that current and former administration officials would not be permitted to testify before Congress, characterizing Congress’ investigations as efforts to “harass” the president. That month, former White House lawyer Don McGahn ignored a House Judiciary Committee  subpoena. And in early June, the White House directed Annie Donaldson, who had served as McGahn’s chief of staff, and Hope Hicks, who had been White House communications director, to ignore the committee’s subpoenas for testimony and documents.

But it hasn’t just been the White House that has been rejecting Congress’ oversight authority. Executive branch agencies have also been following Trump’s lead in “fighting all the subpoenas.” In early April, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin had — despite a law instructing his department to comply with such requests from the House Ways and Means Committee — refused to turn over the president’s tax returns, admitting that the Treasury had discussed the issue with the White House. The next month, Attorney General William Barr failed to appear at a Judiciary Committee hearing, defying a subpoena for the unredacted Mueller report and its underlying evidence.

The administration also has been uncooperative in the investigation of the decision to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census, an issue currently before the Supreme Court. Barr directed Justice Department official John Gore not to comply with a subpoena for testimony about the department’s involvement in the decision, and Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross has also refused to testify or provide requested documents about the citizenship question.

American Oversight is investigating agencies across the federal government to find out whether and to what extent the White House has directed agency officials to match its defiance of congressional requests.

Updates

Open Questions About President Trump’s Abuses of Office

December 28, 2020
Trump’s time as president was defined by multiple financial conflicts of interest and unprecedented abuses of power that touched nearly every aspect of public life — and there’s still a lot the American public needs to know.

American Oversight’s 2019 in Review: Nine Important Stories We Uncovered

December 27, 2019
From Rudy Giuliani to Stephen Miller, and from threats to democracy in the states to corruption in Trump's cabinet, here's where the paper trail took us in 2019.

Why Trump Has Met the Standard for Obstruction of Congress

December 18, 2019
The power of impeachment exists to check a president who refuses to recognize the constitutional separation of powers.

American Oversight Statement on Impeachment Inquiry

September 25, 2019
An impeachment investigation is absolutely warranted in light of the extraordinary allegations about President Trump's dealings with Ukraine.

Trump’s Obstruction of Congressional Oversight Has Been Unprecedented — Now We’re Suing the Administration for Stonewalling Our Investigation

September 19, 2019
To shed light on the executive branch's stonewalling, American Oversight today filed two lawsuits for records of communications between the White House and five Trump administration agencies.
Show all updates

Related Documents

December 16, 2022

CIA Records Released in Response to Request for Directives Limiting CIA Cooperation with Congressional Committees

Central Intelligence Agency
Agency Record
December 2, 2022

EPA Records Released in Response to Request for Communications Between Agency lawyers and the White House

Environmental Protection Agency
Agency Record
June 30, 2021

HUD Records of Communications with White House Counsel and Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Housing and Urban Development
Agency Record
February 19, 2021

Commerce Communications with White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Commerce
Agency Record
December 1, 2020

OMB Records Regarding the FBI Headquarters Consolidation Project

White House - Office of Management and Budget
Agency Record
October 7, 2020

GSA Communications with the White House Concerning Congressional Oversight

General Services Administration
Agency Record
August 25, 2020

Treasury Records of Communications with White House Counsel Staff Concerning Congressional Oversight

Department of the Treasury
Agency Record
June 17, 2020

DOI Records of Communications with White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Interior
Agency Record
May 6, 2020

DOJ Communications Regarding the FBI Headquarters Consolidation Project

Department of Justice
Agency Record
April 17, 2020

Complaint: American Oversight v. CIA, NSA – Directives on Cooperation with Congress

Central Intelligence Agency, DOD - National Security Agency
Litigation
February 28, 2020

FOIA Seeking Directives Limiting NSA Cooperation with Congressional Committees

Department of Defense, DOD - National Security Agency
FOIA Request
February 28, 2020

FOIA Seeking Directives Limiting CIA Cooperation with Congressional Committees

Central Intelligence Agency
FOIA Request
September 19, 2019

Complaint: American Oversight v. GSA, HUD, Treasury, and Commerce – Communications Regarding Congressional Investigations

Department of Commerce, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of the Treasury, General Services Administration
Litigation
September 19, 2019

Complaint: American Oversight v. DOJ – White House Communications Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice
Litigation
September 17, 2019

NRR from VA Regarding Records Communications with White House Counsel Staff Concerning Congressional Oversight

Department of Veterans Affairs
Agency Reply
September 16, 2019

NRR from VA Regarding Communications Concerning Congressional Oversight of the Executive Branch

Department of Veterans Affairs
Agency Reply
September 6, 2019

No Records Response from GSA Regarding Communications with the White House Concerning Congressional Oversight

General Services Administration
Agency Reply
July 19, 2019

FOIA to Commerce Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Commerce
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to FEMA Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Homeland Security, DHS - Federal Emergency Management Agency
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to DHS Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Homeland Security
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to HUD Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Housing and Urban Development
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to Education Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Education
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to Interior Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Interior
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to GSA Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

General Services Administration
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to Treasury Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Treasury
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to EPA Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Environmental Protection Agency
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to DOJ Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to FBI Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice, DOJ - Federal Bureau of Investigation
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to HHS Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Health and Human Services
FOIA Request
July 19, 2019

FOIA to VA Seeking Communications with White House Officials Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Veterans Affairs
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to Commerce Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Commerce
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to FEMA Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Homeland Security, DHS - Federal Emergency Management Agency
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to DHS Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Homeland Security
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to HUD Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Housing and Urban Development
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to ED Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Education
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to DOI Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Interior
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to GSA Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

General Services Administration
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to Treasury Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Treasury
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to EPA Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Environmental Protection Agency
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to DOJ Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to FBI Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice, DOJ - Federal Bureau of Investigation
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to HHS Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Health and Human Services
FOIA Request
June 24, 2019

FOIA to VA Seeking Records Reflecting Communications Between the Agency and the White House Counsel Staff Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Veterans Affairs
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to Commerce Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Commerce
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to Commerce Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Commerce
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to FEMA Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Homeland Security, DHS - Federal Emergency Management Agency
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to FEMA Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Health and Human Services, DHS - Federal Emergency Management Agency
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to DHS Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Homeland Security
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to DHS Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Commerce
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to HUD Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Housing and Urban Development
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to HUD Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Housing and Urban Development
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to ED Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Education
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to ED Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Education
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to DOI Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Interior
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to DOI Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Interior
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to GSA Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

General Services Administration
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to GSA Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

General Services Administration
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to Treasury Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Treasury
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to Treasury Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of the Treasury
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to EPA Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Environmental Protection Agency
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to EPA Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Environmental Protection Agency
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to DOJ Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to FBI Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice, DOJ - Federal Bureau of Investigation
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to FBI Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Justice, DOJ - Federal Bureau of Investigation
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to HHS Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Health and Human Services
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to HHS Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Health and Human Services
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to VA Seeking Communications Between Agency Lawyers and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Veterans Affairs
FOIA Request
June 11, 2019

FOIA to VA Seeking Communications Between the Agency and the White House Regarding Congressional Oversight

Department of Veterans Affairs
FOIA Request
June 10, 2019

FOIA to Multiple Agencies Seeking Guidance Regarding Congressional Oversight Requests and Subpoenas

Department of Commerce, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of the Interior, Department of the Treasury, Department of Veterans Affairs, DHS - Federal Emergency Management Agency, DOJ - Federal Bureau of Investigation, Environmental Protection Agency, General Services Administration
FOIA Request
February 6, 2019

Withheld Records from DOJ Regarding Policies for Responding to Congressional Committees

Department of Justice
Agency Reply