The Trump Administration’s Poor Coordination with States on Pandemic Response

The absence of strong federal leadership, states have been left to determine their own “reopening” strategies and even compete with one another for medical supplies and personal protective equipment. We’re examining the Trump administration’s distribution of resources and information to learn more about the federal government’s response to the needs of various states, whether those states are led by his allies or his critics.
Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, and President Donald Trump in December 2018

Respirators, ventilators, all of the equipment — try getting it yourselves,” President Donald Trump told governors on March 16, 2020. Just a few days earlier, the president had defiantly announced, “I don’t take responsibility at all” when asked about the administration’s failure to provide widespread access to coronavirus testing.

The poor coordination between the federal government and states during the pandemic has been defined not just by the president’s abdication of responsibility, but also by his attacks on state leaders critical of his response. From smearing Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Twitter (and reportedly telling Vice President not to call her) to telling reporters that Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker “couldn’t do his job, so we had to help him,” the first months of the pandemic painted a picture of an administration intent on forcing states to go it alone.

“Desperate for medical equipment, states encounter a beleaguered national stockpile,” read one Washington Post headline from late March. Reporting in that article suggested that states were receiving aid and supplies unequally, and American Oversight is looking into whether the federal government is favoring or disfavoring states, and into how the administration is addressing the spread of Covid-19 through Native American communities

The lack of central leadership continued into the summer, as the president’s political interests, rather than science and safety, have apparently remained the White House’s primary navigator in its pandemic response. Testing capacity remains worryingly low, leaving labs and state leaders concerned about preparations for the fall. As states experience case surges at different times and rates, it is essential for the public to know how the Trump administration is coordinating with state and local leaders to respond to the ongoing crisis.

Updates

Covid-19 Oversight News: Rising Case Numbers, Vaccine Progress, and the Pandemic in Prisons

November 23, 2020
For the latest news on the pandemic, as well as updates on various oversight investigations, sign up for our weekly Covid-19 Oversight News email.

News Roundup: Overstepping Authority and Undermining Democracy

November 19, 2020
It’s now been nearly two weeks since Biden was declared the winner of the presidential election, but President Trump and his most partisan supporters continue their attempts to thwart the will of U.S. voters.

Covid-19 Oversight News: The Pandemic Surges, Dubious Tests and Treatments, and Change on the Horizon

November 9, 2020
For the latest news on the pandemic, as well as updates on various oversight investigations, sign up for our weekly Covid-19 Oversight News email.

News Roundup: Out of Control

October 30, 2020
The pandemic continues to hit new case records, and the Trump administration is finding new ways to flout longstanding ethics requirements.

Open Questions About Trump Administration Policies

October 29, 2020
The tragically botched pandemic response and devastating practice of separating immigrant families are just some of the Trump administration’s actions that bear further scrutiny.
Show all updates

Related Documents

October 27, 2020

No Records Response from Hidalgo County, Texas, Regarding Communications to the Federal Government in 2020

Texas - Hidalgo County
Agency Reply
October 17, 2020

Fla. Governor Records Regarding Communications about Safe Election Procedures

Florida Office of the Governor
Agency Record
October 1, 2020

No Records Response from the Fla. Governor Regarding Emails with RNC or Trump Campaign

Florida Office of the Governor
Agency Reply
September 17, 2020

CDC Records of SharePoint Messages Regarding Covid-19

Department of Health and Human Services, HHS - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Agency Record
September 9, 2020

Fla. Senate Communications Regarding Safe Election Procedures

Florida Senate
Agency Record
September 1, 2020

FOIA to ED Seeking Comms with Education Groups About Coronavirus Funding

Department of Education
FOIA Request
August 26, 2020

No Records Response from Texas Governor Regarding Communications with Hospitals in the Rio Grande Valley

Texas Office of the Governor
Agency Reply
August 25, 2020

No Records Response from the Texas Lieutenant Governor Regarding Communications Containing Key Terms Related to Coronavirus

Texas Office of the Governor
Agency Reply
August 25, 2020

No Records Response from the Texas Lieutenant Governor Regarding Communications with Hospital Facilities About Covid-19

Texas Office of the Governor
Agency Reply
August 25, 2020

No Records Response from the Texas Office of the Lieutenant Governor Regarding Communications with Select Counties

Texas Office of the Governor
Agency Reply
August 24, 2020

Hidalgo County, Texas, Records Regarding COVID-19 from June to July

Texas - Hidalgo County
Agency Record
August 6, 2020

No Records Response from the NY Governor’s Office Regarding Covid-19 Testing and Emergency Response

New York Office of the Governor
Agency Reply
August 4, 2020

Wis. Rep. Steineke Emails Regarding April 7 Election and Coronavirus Response

Wisconsin Senate
Agency Record
July 31, 2020

No Records Response from the Kentucky Secretary of State Regarding Cares Act Funding for Elections

Kentucky Secretary of State
Agency Reply
July 22, 2020

Wis. Elections Commission Records Regarding Cares Act Funding for Elections

Wisconsin Elections Commission
Agency Record
July 22, 2020

Wis. Elections Commission Records Regarding Cares Act Funding for Elections

Wisconsin Elections Commission
Agency Record
July 22, 2020

Request to the Wis. Elections Commission Seeking Records Regarding CARES Act Funding for Elections

Wisconsin Elections Commission
FOIA Request
July 10, 2020

Washington Department of Health Records of Communications Related to Covid-19 from January to February 2020

Washington State Department of Health
Agency Record
July 10, 2020

Washington Department of Health Covid-19 Communications with the Federal Government from January to May 2020

Washington State Department of Health
Agency Record
May 19, 2020

Palm Beach County, Fla., Records Regarding Processing Guidance Related to Records Requests Concerning Covid-19

Florida - Palm Beach County
Agency Record
May 15, 2020

Ga. Gwinnett County, Ga., Records Related to Election Staff Reduction

Georgia - Gwinnett County
Agency Record
May 15, 2020

No Records Response from New Orleans Mayor’s Office Regarding Communications with Governor’s Office

Louisiana - New Orleans Mayor's Office
Agency Reply
April 15, 2020

Wisc. Sen. Testin Emails Regarding April 7 Election and Coronavirus Response

Wisconsin Senate
Agency Record
March 5, 2020

Request to Washington State Health Department Seeking Communications with the White House, CDC, or HHS

Washington State Department of Health
FOIA Request