Trump Administration Appeals Court Decision Ordering It to Turn Over Communications with Congress About ACA Sabotage

This spring, in a lawsuit brought by American Oversight, a federal judge rejected a Trump administration argument for withholding communications with Congress about Affordable Care Act sabotage. Now, the administration is appealing that decision.

In early 2017, as the administration and congressional Republicans made what was ultimately a failed attempt to “repeal and replace” the ACA, then–Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney reportedly sent a secret letter to right-wing Freedom Caucus members detailing executive branch options for weakening the law. American Oversight filed Freedom of Information Act requests with OMB and the Department of Health and Human Services for communications between those agencies and Congress about such potential administrative actions.

American Oversight took the administration to court to force the release of the records, including the Freedom Caucus letter. But the materials produced by the agencies contained heavy redactions of information that they argued fell under the exemption for “inter-agency or intra-agency” deliberations — even though Congress is, of course, not an “agency.”

HHS and OMB’s argument relied on what is known as the “consultant corollary,” which allows outside consultant to be considered as acting “akin to an agency employee.” In April, Judge Amy Berman Jackson rejected this argument — the exemption could only apply to outside consultants acting as neutral parties, and members of Congress are unable to stand in the shoes of agency employees because they are advancing their own (or their constituents’) interests.

The administration’s efforts to conceal the substance of these communications with Congress has now extended to appealing Jackson’s decision. The argument for congressional communications to be considered as falling under the “consultant corollary” would dramatically expand the scope of the exemption, giving the government an argument to support withholding communications with virtually any outside interest group or lobbyist.

Related Blog Posts

September 6, 2019

News Roundup: Trump’s Enthusiastic Support for New Drug Raises Questions

Council on Environmental Quality, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Treasury, Department of Transportation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Environmental Protection Agency, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Food and Drug Administration, Georgia Department of Driver Services, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Securities and Exchange Commission, Texas Attorney General
News
August 27, 2019

Investigating HHS Secretary Alex Azar’s Connections to Pharmaceutical Companies

Department of Health and Human Services
Investigation Update
August 13, 2019

More Examples of Personal Email Use and Heavy-Handed Outside Influence at the VA

Department of Veterans Affairs
Investigation Update
News
June 4, 2019

Documents Reveal Extent of Koch-Funded VA Privatization Group’s Influence

Department of Veterans Affairs
Investigation Update
May 24, 2019

News Roundup: Congressional Hearing Shows and No-Shows

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of Transportation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Taylor County - Florida
News
May 1, 2019

The Imperial Presidency and the End of Congressional Oversight

Congress, White House
News
April 29, 2019

The Dangers of Constitutional Hardball

Congress, Department of Justice, White House
News
April 5, 2019

News Roundup: Turning to the Courts

Congress, Department of Agriculture, Department of Defense, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of the Interior, Department of the Treasury, Department of Transportation, Environmental Protection Agency, Federal Aviation Administration, Federal Housing Finance Agency, Food and Drug Administration, General Services Administration, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Office of Management and Budget, White House
News
April 3, 2019

The Trump Administration’s Disrespect for Constitutional Checks and Balances Earns It Congressional Subpoenas

Congress, White House
News
April 3, 2019

What Congressional Subpoena Power Means for Oversight

Congress, White House
News
April 2, 2019

Federal Judge Rejects Administration’s Argument for Withholding Communications with Congress about ACA Sabotage

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
News
March 27, 2019

Closing the Corruption-Breeding Loopholes the Trump Administration Has Exploited

Congress, Office of Government Ethics
News
March 15, 2019

News Roundup: Sunshine Week Draws to a Close

News
March 14, 2019

Three Ways to Fix the Freedom of Information Act

Congress
News
March 8, 2019

Watchdogs Sue HHS Following Women’s Health Website Overhaul

Department of Health and Human Services
News
March 1, 2019

HHS Secretary Azar Calendars Show Multiple Meetings with Conservative Health-Care Groups

Department of Health and Human Services
News
February 27, 2019

Lying to Congress Rarely Results in Charges — Until Now. Here’s How Others in Trump’s Circle Could Be in Trouble

News
February 21, 2019

New Lawsuit Seeks HHS Communications with Anti-Abortion Groups

Department of Health and Human Services
News
March 16, 2018

Sunshine Week Blog: FOIAs Will Continue Until Accountability Improves

News
March 9, 2018

American Oversight Sues HHS and CMS for Verma Ethics Records

Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Department of Health and Human Services
News
January 16, 2018

Video: Breaking Down Our Lawsuit with HHS, OMB, and Congress

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
October 17, 2017

Health Care Lawsuit: Fighting for Transparency

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
Investigation Update
October 17, 2017

5 Questions for Attorney General Sessions

Department of Justice
September 15, 2017

Congress Enters Legal Fight to Block Release of Obamacare Repeal Emails

Congress, Department of Health and Human Services
Investigation Update
September 13, 2017

“News to Me!” – Inside the Health Care Emails

Office of Management and Budget
Investigation Update
September 7, 2017

Third Set of Health Care Emails Again Shows Trump Administration Effort to Hide Negotiations

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
Investigation Update
August 11, 2017

Ethics Watchdog Sues Treasury to Obtain Emails with House Financial Services Committee

Department of the Treasury, National Credit Union Administration
Investigation Update
August 2, 2017

New Health Care Documents Show Effort to Hide Details of Negotiations

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
Investigation Update
July 31, 2017

Open Letter to Rep. Gowdy: Do Your Job

News
July 25, 2017

Call for Senate Investigation of Trump Interference in US Attorney Selection Process

Department of Justice
News
July 20, 2017

American Oversight Sues HHS and OMB For Secret Trump Letter Outlining Plan to Weaken Obamacare

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget, White House
Investigation Update
July 11, 2017

Investigation of Trump Administration Actions and the AT&T-Time Warner Merger

Department of Justice
News
May 12, 2017

Letter to Burr and Warner: Senate Should Request Trump-Comey Tapes

Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation
Investigation Update
May 9, 2017

Ethics Watchdog Challenges Congressional Moves to Limit Government Transparency

Comptroller of the Currency, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of the Treasury, Federal Housing Finance Agency, Federal Reserve, National Credit Union Administration
Investigation Update
May 5, 2017

Letter to Senator Grassley: Renew Leadership on Ethics and Transparency

Office of Government Ethics
Investigation Update
May 4, 2017

Watchdog Files Lawsuit, Seeks Injunction for HHS, OMB Health Care Negotiation Record

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
Investigation Update
March 23, 2017

American Oversight Demands Release of Secret Health Care Negotiations

Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Management and Budget
Investigation Update
March 22, 2017

Statement on Intelligence Committee Chairman Nunes’ Actions

Investigation Update
March 17, 2017

American Oversight Calls on Congress to Investigate Trump Aide’s Reported Ties to Nazi Group

Office of Government Ethics, White House
News