DACA Announcement Reflects Lack of Seriousness About the Law

By: John BiesChief Counsel

On September 5, Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program (DACA) is “being rescinded” because it is “unconstitutional,” asserting that the policy has “enormous constitutional infirmities.” There may be an intense political debate about the policy merits of DACA, but the attorney general portrayed his decision not as a policy judgment but rather as a result compelled by law. What Sessions and the Department of Justice (DOJ) did not provide was a robust legal analysis supporting this contention.

This is a problem.

Normally when DOJ rests major policy changes on a legal determination, it explains the legal analysis supporting those decisions. Whether you agree or disagree with the Obama administration’s decisions to use military force in Libya, to expand the DACA program to provide deferred action to parents of U.S. citizens, or to cease defending the Defense of Marriage Act in court—each of these decisions was accompanied by a detailed legal explanation of the administration’s position.

Providing a public explanation of the administration’s legal rationale promotes government accountability and ensures that the public can evaluate the government’s legal claims.  And the obligation to provide a serious legal explanation for the government’s position helps to prevent policy making driven by the ipse dixit assertions of politically motivated actors.

DOJ’s failure to provide any serious legal support for the attorney general’s claims about the constitutionality of DACA reflects an apparent lack of seriousness about the law in the Trump administration as a whole. Why did the Trump administration believe its military strikes against the Syrian regime were legal? The public has been left to guess. Why wasn’t it problematic under the Emoluments Clause that the Trump Organization, privately held in large part by the president, receives substantial amounts of money from foreign governments? The public only found out the government’s views in litigation filings after the arrangements were challenged in court. From the travel ban to claims about the application of ethics requirements to White House employees, the Trump administration has staked out controversial legal positions while failing to provide any serious legal justification for them unless required by the courts.

Normally, in the context of litigation, DOJ defends any statute or administrative action where there are reasonable arguments to defend it in court, not based on its own judgments about the ultimate merits. This standard is intended to prevent political actors at DOJ from substituting their personal judgments for a determination of the law by a court.  The instances where DOJ has departed from this approach are rare, controversial, and deserving of a thorough explanation and public discussion.

The 2014 Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) opinion finding that President Obama’s deferred action program for parents of U.S. citizens is lawful rests on similar legal footing as DACA and is hard, if not impossible, to reconcile with the legal conclusions about DACA advanced by Sessions.  There is no public indication that the opinion has been rescinded or replaced by OLC or expressly overruled by the attorney general. American Oversight has filed 3 FOIA requests with DOJ to determine if the 2014 OLC opinion remains the official position of the U.S. government and what legal guidance from DOJ’s career professionals, if any, Sessions used to inform his statements about DACA.

Related Blog Posts

August 7, 2020

American Oversight Sues for Records of Federal Protest Crackdown

Customs and Border Protection, Department of Defense, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, National Guard Bureau
August 4, 2020

Investigations Update: DHS Intelligence Efforts in Portland, the Politicization of Key Government Agency, and the Pandemic’s Impact on Census

Arizona Attorney General, Census Bureau, Department of Commerce, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of Transportation, Georgia Office of the Governor, Office of Intelligence and Analysis, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, State Office of the Inspector General, U.S. Agency for Global Media, U.S. Election Assistance Commission
July 30, 2020

News Roundup: Neither Rain Nor Snow Nor … Trump’s Political Interference

Department of Education, Department of Justice, United States Postal Service
July 28, 2020

Investigations Update: ‘Burrowing In,’ Voter Fraud Task Forces, and Federal Law Enforcement

Agency for International Development, Arizona Attorney General, Arizona Office of the Governor, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Citizenship and Immigration Services, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Defense, Department of Education, Department of Energy, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of Labor, Department of State, Department of the Interior, Department of the Treasury, DHS Office of the Inspector General, DOJ Office of the Inspector General, Environmental Protection Agency, Executive Office for Immigration Review, Florida Department of State, Florida Office of the Attorney General, Florida Office of the Governor, Food and Drug Administration, Georgia Secretary of State, Health Resources and Services Administration, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Kentucky Attorney General, Kentucky Secretary of State, Millennium Challenge Corporation, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Nevada Secretary of State, New York Office of the Governor, New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, Office of Management and Budget, Office of Personnel Management, Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, Oklahoma Attorney General, Oklahoma Office of the Governor, Oregon Office of the Governor, Portland Independent Police Review Division, Portland Mayor's Office, Portland Police Bureau, Small Business Administration, U.S. Agency for Global Media, United States Secret Service, Wisconsin Elections Commission
July 24, 2020

News Roundup: The Political Theater of ‘Operation Legend’

Customs and Border Protection, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, State Office of the Inspector General
July 21, 2020

Investigations Update: Trump Administration’s Occupation of Portland, CDC Hospital Data, and the Republican Convention

California Department of Public Health, California Department of Technology, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Council of the Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of Transportation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Drug Enforcement Administration, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Florida Department of Health, Florida Department of Management Services, Florida Office of the Governor, Food and Drug Administration, Georgia Department of Public Health, Georgia Office of the Governor, Georgia Technology Authority, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Jacksonville Mayor’s Office - Florida, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, New York Office of the Governor, New York State Department of Health, New York State Office of Information Technology Services, Office of Information Policy, Small Business Administration, Texas Department of Health and Human Services, Texas Office of the Governor, U.S. Marshals Service, Waukesha County - Wisconsin
July 17, 2020

The Trump Administration’s Dangerous Escalation of Aggression Against Portland Protesters

Customs and Border Protection, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Drug Enforcement Administration, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Office of Information Policy, U.S. Marshals Service
July 14, 2020

Investigations Update: Militarization of Police, Covid-19 in Migrant Detention Centers, and Barr’s Political Interference

Central Intelligence Agency, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Defense Logistics Agency, Department of Defense, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, General Services Administration, Office of Legal Counsel, Palm Beach County - Florida, Transportation Security Administration
July 8, 2020

Investigations Update: Mike Pompeo’s Abuses of Office, Trump’s Loyalty Purges, and Caring for Uninsured Covid-19 Patients

Department of Agriculture, Department of Defense, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Florida Department of State, Florida House of Representatives, Florida Senate, Health Resources and Services Administration, Iowa Office of the Governor, Iowa Secretary of State, National Credit Union Administration, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Nevada Office of the Governor, Nevada Secretary of State, New Hampshire Office of the Governor, North Carolina House of Representatives, Office of Management and Budget, Office of Personnel Management, Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, Ohio House of Representatives, Ohio Office of the Governor, Ohio Secretary of State, Ohio Senate, Small Business Administration, Texas House of Representatives, Texas Office of the Governor, Texas Secretary of State, Texas Senate
June 30, 2020

Investigations Update: Family Separation, Unmarked Law Enforcement, and Trump’s Campaign Rallies

Agency for International Development, Arizona Department of Health Services, Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco Firearms and Explosives, Cameron County - Texas, Customs and Border Protection, Dallas County - Texas, Defense Intelligence Agency, Department of Agriculture, Department of Defense, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Army, Department of the Interior, Drug Enforcement Administration, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Florida Department of Health, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, National Guard Bureau, National Park Service, New Hampshire Attorney General, New Hampshire Office of the Governor, New Hampshire Secretary of State, North Carolina Department of Health, Nueces County - Texas, Oklahoma Department of Health, Securities and Exchange Commission, Tarrant County - Texas, Texas Attorney General, Transportation Security Administration, Travis County - Texas, Tulsa County - Oklahoma, U.S. Marshals Service
June 19, 2020

Barr’s Policing Commission Undermines Community Trust and Violates Federal Law

Department of Justice
June 19, 2020

News Roundup: The Administration’s Failure to Confront Two National Crises

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Citizenship and Immigration Services, Civil Division, Civil Rights Division, Department of Agriculture, Department of Defense, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Treasury, Department of Transportation, Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Florida Department of Health, Florida Office of the Governor, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Jacksonville Mayor’s Office - Florida, National Credit Union Administration, Office of Science and Technology Policy, Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections, Small Business Administration, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Transportation Office of the Inspector General, U.S. International Development Finance Corporation, United States Postal Service, Wisconsin Department of Health Services
June 12, 2020

News Roundup: Georgia’s Disastrous Election, the Administration’s Alarming Protest Response, and Barr’s Troubling Tenure

Baltimore Mayor's Office, Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco Firearms and Explosives, Citizenship and Immigration Services, Civil Division, Customs and Border Protection, Defense Intelligence Agency, Department of Defense, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Air Force, Department of the Interior, District of Columbia Mayor's Office, District of Columbia Metropolitan Police Department, Drug Enforcement Administration, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Florida Department of State, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Justice Management Division, Miami-Dade County - Florida, National Guard Bureau, National Park Service, Nevada Secretary of State, New Jersey Department of Human Services, New York City Department for the Aging, New York City Office of the Mayor, New York Police Department, New York State Department of Health, New York State Office for the Aging, North Carolina, North Carolina House of Representatives, North Carolina Senate, Office of Information Policy, Office of Intelligence and Analysis, Office of Management and Budget, Ohio House of Representatives, Ohio Secretary of State, Ohio Senate, State Office of the Inspector General, Texas Secretary of State, Transportation Security Administration, U.S. Marshals Service, United States Postal Service, United States Secret Service, Wisconsin Elections Commission
June 5, 2020

News Roundup: Trump and Barr Unleash Attack on Protesters — and the Constitution

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Citizenship and Immigration Services, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Commerce, Department of Defense, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of the Army, Department of Transportation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Executive Office for Immigration Review, Federal Aviation Administration, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Florida Department of State, Florida House of Representatives, Florida Office of the Governor, Florida Senate, Food and Drug Administration, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, King County - Washington, National Guard Bureau, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Nevada Department of Health and Human Services, Transportation Security Administration, U.S. International Development Finance Corporation, U.S. Marshals Service, United States Secret Service
June 1, 2020

Tips for Filing Public Records Requests in Your State or City

May 29, 2020

News Roundup: A Somber Week After Memorial Day

Brown County - Wisconsin, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Customs and Border Protection, Dane County - Wisconsin, Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency, Department of Defense, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Army, Environmental Protection Agency, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Food and Drug Administration, General Services Administration, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Milwaukee County - Wisconsin, National Security Agency, North Carolina Department of Health, North Carolina Office of the Governor, Office of Information Policy, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Outagamie County - Wisconsin, U.S. Agency for Global Media, U.S. Department of the Navy, Waukesha County - Wisconsin, Winnebago County - Wisconsin
May 22, 2020

News Roundup: One Firing, Multiple Scandals

Agency for International Development, Athens-Clarke County - Georgia, Bexar County - Texas, Cobb County - Georgia, Dallas County - Texas, Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency, Department of Defense, Department of Education, Department of Energy, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Interior, Environmental Protection Agency, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Georgia Department of Administrative Services, Georgia Department of Corrections, Georgia Secretary of State, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Harris County - Texas, Office of Management and Budget, Office of Personnel Management, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, Small Business Administration, State Office of the Inspector General, Texas Department of State Health Services, Travis County - Texas, Webb County - Texas
May 21, 2020

American Oversight Sues Administration for Documentation of Detention Center Covid Response

Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Immigration and Customs Enforcement
May 15, 2020

News Roundup: The Subversion of Justice at the Justice Department

Cobb County - Georgia, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Agriculture, Department of Commerce, Department of Education, Department of Energy, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of the Interior, Department of the Treasury, Department of Transportation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Food and Drug Administration, Georgia Department of Corrections, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Louisiana Department of Health, Louisiana Office of the Governor, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, New Orleans Mayor's Office, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, New York City Office of the Mayor, New York Office of the Governor, New York State Department of Health, Office of Legal Counsel, Office of Management and Budget, Small Business Administration, U.S. International Development Finance Corporation, United States Postal Service, Wisconsin Elections Commission
May 12, 2020

Chaos, Confusion and Obfuscation at DHS Around Family Separation

Citizenship and Immigration Services, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement
May 1, 2020

News Roundup: Protecting the Right to Vote During a Pandemic

Arizona Department of Emergency and Military Affairs, Arizona Department of Homeland Security, Arizona-Mexico Commission, Central Intelligence Agency, Cobb County - Georgia, Customs and Border Protection, DeKalb County - Georgia, Department of Agriculture, Department of Defense, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of the Treasury, District of Columbia Metropolitan Police Department, Essex County - New Jersey, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Florida Department of Economic Opportunity, Florida Department of State, Florida Office of the Governor, Food and Drug Administration, Fulton County - Georgia, Georgia Secretary of State, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Indiana Secretary of State, Iowa Secretary of State, Kentucky Secretary of State, Kentucky State Board of Elections, Louisiana Department of Public Safety and Corrections, New Orleans, Office of Information Policy, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Richmond County - Georgia, Texas Attorney General, Texas Secretary of State, Wisconsin Elections Commission, Yuma County - Arizona
April 24, 2020

News Roundup: Miracle Drugs and Trump’s Alternate Reality

Albany-Dougherty County - Georgia, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Chatham County - Georgia, Citizenship and Immigration Services, Cobb County - Georgia, Cook County - Illinois, Customs and Border Protection, DeKalb County - Georgia, Department of Agriculture, Department of Commerce, Department of Defense, Department of Energy, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Treasury, Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Florida Department of Corrections, Food and Drug Administration, Food Safety and Inspection Service, Fulton County - Georgia, General Services Administration, Georgia Department of Community Health, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, King County - Washington, Macon-Bibb County - Georgia, Muscogee County - Georgia, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Office of Management and Budget, Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, Richmond County - Georgia, Texas Department of Health and Human Services, Veterans Health Administration
April 17, 2020

News Roundup: Who Stands to Gain?

Department of Agriculture, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of the Treasury, Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Reserve, Florida, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Florida Department of Health, Florida Division of Emergency Management, Florida Office of the Governor, Georgia Department of Administrative Services, Georgia Department of Public Health, Georgia Office of the Governor, Georgia Secretary of State, Small Business Administration, Tybee Island City - Georgia, Wisconsin Department of Military Affairs, Wisconsin Senate, Wisconsin State Assembly
April 3, 2020

News Roundup: Whose Stockpile, and Which States?

Broward County - Florida, Bureau of Industry and Security, California Office of the Governor, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Central Intelligence Agency, Department of Agriculture, Department of Commerce, Department of Defense, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of Labor, Department of State, Department of the Treasury, Duval County - Florida, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Florida Office of the Governor, Food and Drug Administration, Gadsden County - Florida, Hendry County - Florida, Jackson County - Florida, King County - Washington, Leon County - Florida, Miami-Dade County - Florida, Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, New York Office of the Governor, Office of Management and Budget, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Ohio Office of the Governor, Oklahoma Department of Health, Oklahoma Office of the Governor, Osceola County - Florida, Texas Attorney General, Texas Office of the Governor, Washington Office of the Governor
March 27, 2020

News Roundup: Transparency and Oversight Are More Important Than Ever

Bartow County - Georgia, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Cobb County - Georgia, Customs and Border Protection, DeKalb County - Georgia, Department of Commerce, Department of Energy, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of State, Department of the Treasury, Drug Enforcement Administration, Executive Office for Immigration Review, Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, Federal Election Commission, Florida Department of State, Florida Office of the Attorney General, Florida Office of the Governor, Fulton County - Georgia, General Services Administration, Georgia Office of the Governor, Georgia Secretary of State, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, National Security Division, Office of Management and Budget, Office of Personnel Management, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, Tennessee Valley Authority, Texas Attorney General, Texas Office of the Governor, Texas Secretary of State, U.S. Marshals Service
March 17, 2020

Floridians with Prior Felonies Need to Pay Fines Before Voting — But Documents Reveal the State Can’t Properly Track What They Owe

Florida Department of State, Hernando County - Florida, Hillsborough County - Florida, Leon County - Florida, Martin County - Florida, Okaloosa County - Florida
March 6, 2020

News Roundup: Rising Coronavirus Fears and Sinking Public Trust

Administration for Children and Families, Agency for International Development, Briscoe County - Texas, Bureau of Land Management, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services, Cobb County - Georgia, Criminal Division, Customs and Border Protection, Department of Commerce, Department of Defense, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Justice, Department of Labor, Department of State, Department of the Interior, Department of the Treasury, Department of Transportation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Federal Reserve, Food and Drug Administration, Freestone County - Texas, Georgia Bureau of Investigation, Georgia Department of Driver Services, Georgia Secretary of State, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Hall County - Texas, Hill County - Texas, Hood County - Texas, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Jones County - Texas, Kendall County - Texas, King County - Washington, Lavaca County - Texas, Leon County - Texas, Limestone County - Texas, Loving County - Texas, Morris County - Texas, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Office of Information Policy, Office of Management and Budget, Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, Scurry County - Texas, Starr County - Texas, Swisher County - Texas, Texas Secretary of State, Veterans Health Administration, Victoria County - Texas, Washington State Department of Health
February 7, 2020

News Roundup: Acquittal Isn’t the End

Cobb County - Georgia, DeKalb County - Georgia, Department of Energy, Department of Justice, Department of State, Florida Department of State, Fulton County - Georgia, Georgia Secretary of State, Gwinnett County - Georgia, Office of Management and Budget
October 4, 2019

News Roundup: The Public Needs Answers

Central Intelligence Agency, Department of Energy, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of Labor, Department of State
July 30, 2019

American Oversight Sues Justice Department over Brooklyn Jail’s Inhumane Winter Conditions

Department of Justice
May 17, 2019

News Roundup: Investigating State-Level Threats to Democracy

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Department of Education, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of State, Department of the Interior, Department of Veterans Affairs, Environmental Protection Agency, Florida, Georgia, Texas
March 13, 2019

Two Years of American Oversight

February 15, 2019

News Roundup: Citizenship, the Census and the Constitution

Department of Commerce, Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice
January 31, 2019

Lawsuit Seeks Emails of DOJ Official Involved in Controversial Civil Rights Decisions

Department of Justice
January 24, 2019

Checking Up on Trump’s Claims that Military Experts Told Him to Ban Transgender Troops

Department of Defense
December 27, 2018

Countdown to Oversight in 2019

January 12, 2018

Justice Department Staffing Up For Its Ill-Conceived Affirmative Action Investigation

Department of Justice
January 2, 2018

New FOIAs Seek Records of Civil Rights Investigations at Department of Education

Department of Education
December 19, 2017

American Oversight Sues DOD to Uncover Truth Behind Trump’s Transgender Ban

Department of Defense
October 4, 2017

DOJ Confirms Harvard Affirmative Action Investigation

Department of Justice